Must restaurant to eat at. Had filet mignon wrapped in bacon with demi glace sauce. Mashed potato and asparagus. Excellent.
181 - 190 of 759 reviews
Sunday Brunch was outstanding. Made to order omelets, Bacon, Sausage, Home Fries, etc.. Fresh fruit and homemade desserts. A special thank you to Kathleen, our hostess (server). My daughter loved your ghost stories..
Very charming and historical landmark. Bar area very noisy had to move to larger dinning room. Had shrimp and linguini, Very good and large portion. Ice cream for dessert, very good. Good service. Thought it was pricey for what we had.
We dinned two evenings at this wonderful Inn a resturant Excellant seafoods and terrific early dinner dpecisls selections Every dish well prepared Excellant taste Good for lunch and Excellant Sunday Brunch The best on Cape outstwnding service
Thank you for your review! We are humbled by your opinion and will do our best to offer a consistently good product with warm friendly service to keep you coming back! Many Thanks, Sheila
For many years we have driven by the Old Yarmouth Inn and thought to ourselves we should try that restaurant sometime. Finally at the recommendation of the Inn keepers where we were staying we made reservations. When we arrived they brought us to the tavern...More
Nothing makes us happier than making a good first impression! We look forward to your next visit and please send our appreciation to your innkeeper for the recommendation. Thank you for taking the time to post your review! Sheila
After our fabulous whale watch we were a bit hungry, so we looked for somewhere nearby, and we chose this spot. The ambience is fair, while it said casual, we felt it it could be a bit "stuffy" for some because it had that "old...More
Thank you for your review. The tavern is, in our opinion, a very casual setting with its dark paneled walls, and the dining room is definitely less so with its Old World Country Toile. Gretchen has a great personality, and we are pleased that you...More
Went there on recommendation of our lodging host. Not disappointed. The service was first class, as was the food. Sheila, the owner, made sure everything was in order and would check on each table to ensure, you, the customer was happy. Great pace with genuine...More
Thank you for your review, and thank you for making the OYI a part of your Cape Cod vacation. We take a lot of pride of not just offering our customers a good meal, we want to offer them an experience that will create a...More
Having visited a number of times for Sunday brunch I can not say enough about how great it is. The selection is excellent and they vary the menu so I have a new choice or two each time I have gone. From their eggs Benedict...More
Thank you for your review of Brunch. Our kitchen staff delivers the "goods" when it comes to the Brunch Buffet and Shannon, Kate, Stacey and AnnMarie ensure that our guests get First Class treatment. We look forward to seeing you again! Sheila
Finally dined at The Old Yarmouth Inn and everything was perfect. From the moment we walked in, we knew we were in for a treat. The restaurant is over 300 years old, very quaint, cozy and elegant all at the same time. The service and...More
You only get one chance to make a first impression and it is gratifying to know that we made such a memorable one for you. Thanks for dining with us and thank you for your review! See you on your next trip to the Cape....More
Mr CW and I had a very pleasant dinner in the bar, rather than the main restaurant (same menu). The food was really good; service was friendly, helpful and attentive. The Inn dates back to 1696 and retains many old features that create a relaxed...More
Thank you for dining with us and thank you for your review that shines the spotlight on the charm of this historic old Inn. I hope your travels bring you back to the Old Yarmouth Inn. Sheila