Stopped in for a pie to bring home. I thought I would try one. I bought the Dutch apple it was delicious not to sweet tons of fresh apples.Was a little pricey but worth every penny. Lots of different pies to choose from. I will...More
1 - 10 of 13 reviews
GREAT pies, however they are a bit pricey! I am not sure if pies in general have gone up that much, maybe I am out of place stating they are a bit on the expensive side?! But the pies and all of their creations are...More
Upon entering for the first time we were not greeted in a friendly manner and it was very off-putting. We were made to feel that we were interrupting or bothersome. Very good baked goods but not sure I want to return as the friendliness that...More
If you like pecan pie, you cannot go wrong here. All other pies are yummy too including the dutch apple. This bakery also stocks their pies at local stores and meat markets in the area. Call ahead and get your name on the list for...More
This is great find the pies are the best I have had in a long time . We got 3 pies Apple Cherry and pecan burbon . All were great everyone wants us to bring them pies home next time.
I've been stopping here for 20+ years (right after stopping down the road at the Turkey Roost). Whenever I head north, Judy's apple pie is a MUST ... how can anyone pack that many apples into one pie? Additionally, we always get a second one...More
In the several years we have been stopping at Judy's I think we have tried every pie they make and have never been disappointed. Although my personal favorite is the strawberry-rhubarb, it is always a tough decision as there are so many delicious looking choices....More
If you love great pie then this is the place to stop! So many different pies it is hard to make a decision. Thes pies aren't just the best in the area, they are as good as any I have had anywhere.
Did not care at all for the coconut creme pie. The texture was such a thick heavy cream fill I couldn't force myself to eat it. Only pie I ever bought from Judy but if that was Judy working there I won't be going back....More
We picked up a cherry pie traveling through the area; it was a Sunday afternoon, and there were quite a few kinds of pie, but some of the more popular were sold out. The server warned us that the cherry pie had turned out a...More