May's has some of the best sweet treats on the Island, with very smooth fudge in many flavors, and some really good Peanut Brittle! Worth the stop for anything from a sample to a pound or two!
1 - 10 of 80 reviews
This place a little different than the others. Some original stuff here for an original store. Goodies like the other places for fudge with some things different. We bought a few pieces and goodies. Nice quaint store.
Another great candy store on the island with fantastic fudge! Hard to decide which one to choose from the many favorful combinations.
Fudge was good but limited to just a few flavors and seemed rather dried out. We did purchase at the end of the day, which may have been our mistake.
Peanut Butter Fudge was great. Chocolate a little too sweet but the Divinity took me back to my child hood. What another great memory to cherish
May's is the arguably oldest fudge shop on the island, and in my opinion the best. It is not a chain, so a ferry ride or mail order are your only options to enjoy May's. Fudge is smooth and creamy, not as sweet as some...More
We were tempted at many fudge shops but chose May's because of the great story of how May's saved the fudge when sugar was scarse.
Sampled my way thru some other fudge shops & chose May's hands down. Not as sweet...creamier....natural flavors come bursting through...and the super understated amazing fact that it's still family owned & staffed since 1930's.. Delightful to talk to granddaughter working in one of the shops....More
One of many Fudge shops locate within the main shopping area. All the shops claim the fudge is made daily, but I suspect this was not sold daily. My fudge was tasty, but stale.It did not have that soft creamy taste or feel. However this...More