I've always tried to understand why so many people rave about this restaurant. I've been there three times in the last 40 years living downriver and still think it's overpriced.
1 - 10 of 105 reviews
Sibley gardens has not changed in 45 years still great. Waitstaff, food and atmosphere is still great. Walleye special, Salmon, and frog legs were ordered and were excellent. Appetizers steak and mushrooms were also great.
I could see why people next to us knew the menu by heart. This place still survives and thrives from it's long time restaurant repeat customer base. I'm very hard to please and always find fault with my meal everywhere i go, but NOT here....More
We were visiting friends on Grosse Ile and decided to have dinner at Sibley Gardens. What a pleasant surprise. My wife had the calves liver which was prepared just the way she likes it. Our friends had the lake perch which was also very good....More
The food... The old style building.. The Atmosphere... and the Service.. Everything is excellent.. Call ahead for a reservation since its always packed.. Remember that it is CLOSED on Sunday...
My all time favorite. Steak Sammy wonderful. All salads, seafood, foul & beef great. Nice comfy atmosphere, separate upscale dining room if u prefer. Great service, nice bar. Locals favorite. U can't go wrong here. Family run for generations.