You can find seafood, but compare to the size, service and the place, the price is surprisingly high.
1 - 10 of 34 reviews
4 cases of fish over ice cooked your way, friendly service and reasonable prices .Been going to this place for years , went back last week and there closed . Sign on window says opening soon , we shall see. Hope fully it will be...More
This is a combination fish market and small restaurant (seating perhaps 16 people). Everything is fresh daily whether for home cooking or from the menu. They are currently undergoing renovation (June) but hopefully other than physical setting nothing will change. Not fancy but pleasant service...More
Wasn't surprised that the place is under renovation. Have been going to Caldwell seafood for 40 years. Thought something funny was going on with store. They stopped taking credit cards a few years ago but didn't admit it. They just told you their machine was...More
I have been buying my seafood and going to the restaurant for a couple of years. The fish is so very fresh and tasty. The meals served in the small confines of the store are nothing less than spectacular. The presentation of the dishes is...More
We love the fresh seafood at this neighborhood place. It's not fancy but the food is tasty and it's a great spot to go in to for a weeknight fish or seafood meal.
We have been here many times, but the last time was horrendous. They did not get deliveries of numerous seafood items that should have been available so we got stuck with what little they had. We never would have gone if we had known this...More
My daughter and I went for dinner on a Friday night. We each had the Lobster Dinner with homemade mash potatoes and fresh vegetables. The food was delicious. She ordered the mussel appetizer, we couldn't believe how many mussels there were!!!Everyone there was so friendly....More
We were disappointed with the food here. The lobster bisque had not a piece of lobster in it, but it wasn't even that. All we could taste was flour and alcohol. It had zero flavor. The clam chowder was not much better. My husband had...More