We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
The sandwiches are out of this world!!! The #1 is amazing! Sergio himself went out of his way when they were closing and I was coming in from a cross country trip to make sandwiches anyway. I couldn’t recommend more
My husband and I ate at Sergio's for the first time. We had no idea how busy it would be at lunchtime! We saw lots of people coming in to pick up orders that they had called in. They do have 6 or 7 tables...and we ate in.
I had the #10 - grilled portabella mushroom, arugula and an artichoke parmesan spread on a ciabatta roll (it also comes with roasted peppers, but I left that off).
It was very good and a large sandwich. I expected to get a hot grilled portabella mushroom cap, but it was small baby bella mushroom pieces that were cold. I was not disappointed.
My husband ordered the antipasto plate. It was very large but he thought that the meat was all too salty and the eggplant was too vinegary. In fact, he felt everything on the plate was kind of one note with all of the marinated veggies. If that's something you like, then this is for you.
We would go back for that sandwich, but maybe not at noon!More
Have ordered some great lunches from Sergio's. Their sandwich board if filled with delicious Italian specialties. A must try and take home is the fresh mozzarella! Yum! Wish they had a bigger seating area. But I'll settle for take out!
Service might be a bit slow but attribute that to the finest in quality and care extended to each customer who walks through the door. No off the shelf here. Each order is filled to perfection. Same clients come back day after day. Great soup....Try to Chicken Pastina.More
wonderful service and the food is authentic Italian cuisine and specialties. I very much enjoy coming here and ordering what I miss during the days when my mom would make these authentic Italian dishes herself
We don't come here often enough, but when we entertain friends or family we try to find time to stop and shop here.
We love the wonderful selection of cheeses that they wrap with care, like little presents. The price of cheese as everyone knows...is getting higher and higher, but here you get the quality and freshness that can't be beat.
We love the great selection of their home made pasta as well. Last time we also tried their marinara sauce and it was delicious.
Spotted a huge round loaf of crusty bread. Could not leave the store without it. It was out of this world good !
There is always a line of people, but don't be discouraged. The efficient and helpful staff makes the wait bearable ....More
Great quality Italian deli food- this is a hidden gem in Denville center, and it is NYC quality. Has a few comfortable tables by the entrance and the deli behind it. Great soups and sandwiches, and good for taking out cheeses, meats and prepared food....Caution: it gets very crowded on Saturdays so if you are in a rush, leave it if there's a crowd.More
It's not a restaurant, it's an Italian specialty store. They are open for lunch and can seat about 15. It's counter service and they will bring it to your table or takeout. It's hard to get seating at lunch time, son best... More
It's not a restaurant, it's an Italian specialty store. They are open for lunch and can seat about 15. It's counter service and they will bring it to your table or takeout. It's hard to get seating at lunch time, son best tonfoneaely or after 1:30p to avoid the lunch rush. Outstanding staff and wonderful food!
They also do call a heads for takeout service to get you in and out quick. Closed Sun/Mon