Cute place to sit and eat with a large selection of healthy food and side orders. Great to grab lunch with groups or alone.
1 - 10 of 34 reviews
Upper Montclair Village looks like a white table cloth and fine dining sort of place. It may be that, but folks who live and work here need a reliable, ordinary looking Formica table kind of sandwich shop that produces far from ordinary creations. Sandwich Theory...More
We have been enjoying the great sandwiches and salads for years at Sandwich Theory. Don't miss the tarragon chicken salad- I've tried to duplicate at home to no avail. Our family each has our favorite "go to" choices. And on occasion there is a surprise...More
Whenever a road trip is scheduled when lunchtime will be spent alert for texting teens driving stupidly at high speeds, a first stop at Sandwich Theory is mandatory. It's important to be sure you're emotionally well-armed and your poor brain is equipped to pour out...More
Nice casual cafe with good choices for lunch. There is limited seating so we usually take it to go. Around the corner is Anderson Park which is a great place to have lunch on one of the benches. Sandwich Theory is only open for breakfast...More
Whenever I am driving a long distance (to the Berkshires, for example) and the trip converges with lunchtime, I make it a habit of calling Sandwich Theory and ordering sandwiches for the road. My personal favorite is #1 with herbed mayo (in place of honey...More
What a wonderful eatery... we ordered and had the meals delivered. They labeled each sandwich per the individual. Had no complaints... my personal fav is the grilled chicken Caesar salad wrap (( they add bacon and provolone)) scrumptious!!! The chili and soups are divine! Office...More
Great panini sandwiches and salads, but what really made me smile was when we opened our to-go bag and saw a few cookies with the message "bonus points for nerd swag". My son was wearing an artsy Star Wars t-shirt that the cashier asked about,...More
This place is nothing spectacular and no better than a homemade sandwich. I had a mediocre turkey sandwich.