Met friends for the two for one lobster dinner on Monday night. Had 2 pound lobsters which were cooked to perfection. Very good service and a comfortable atmosphere.
1 - 10 of 109 reviews
Lots of restaurants to choose from on the 'mile', but the Nautilus is definitely the best. The view of the water is good, but it's the food that will really bring me back. They start with bread and a sweet banana bread that was very...More
Thank you, 4Family4FunNY, for taking the time to write us an excellent review! We’re glad you loved the view and food on your recent visit. We would love to have you and your friends back anytime to try the rest of our menu. We look...More
Overtly racist place. We were shocked in 2017 on long Island to experience this negativity. We made reservations on 9/2/17 reservation was for 10:00 p.m., it was raining and we were 10 minutes left. They took one look at us and said "sorry the kitchen...More
Mattjrose115, thank you for taking the time to inform us about your recent visit and unfortunate incident. We appreciate you taking the time to leave us with your comments on several review platforms. We first want to assure you that at Nautilus Cafe we welcome...More
We recently dined at the Nautilus Cafe and arrived before 6:00 pm for their early dinner. This is a great deal that includes a soup or salad, your choice of an entree and dessert with coffee. The halibut and salmon was excellent. The dining room...More
Where do i start. I have been here a few times and the food does not disappoint ever. The staff is accommodating and the fresh fish is to die for We had a wonderful diner we are very happy with the waiters they serve as...More
Roberto L., we are so happy to hear you enjoyed your meal at Nautilus Cafe, and took some time out of your day to write a great review for us. We take great pride in serving great tasting food made from the finest ingredients, so...More
Went for lobster night the other week and it was fantastic. They had a great menu as well, it took a lot to stick to our plan for lobster night. Service was very good. Daughter had a burger and fish and chips, which were excellent....More
Located on the nautical mile but not on the water side of the street this restaurant caters to families and older diners . The food is delicious and they have a pre-fix menu.
We love this restaurant, it's quiet and scenic. This visit, we had 6 people with us. We arrived before 6:00, and had early bird. Included: soup, salad, entree and dessert. All of us enjoyed our food, mostly specials.
Many visits to this gem of a restaurant make a compelling case for five stars. Every time we go, we are warmly welcomed by the Nautilus Team. It feels much like a private club must feel. Chuck sees me and starts mixing my favorite cocktail...More