Always a must stop during our visits to the area. Pizza & food is delicious, staff is nice and we love it.
1 - 10 of 46 reviews
Out visiting family on Long Island We spent a week in jamesport Went to Lenny's for dinner Food was great !! However service was just average We were party of 8 , we had called ahead to see if they took reservations , seating was...More
I am a regular (and probably biased) This place is just high-quality. It's not the fanciest place around, and at times you wait, the pizza and the food is definitely worth it. Family run. Regular pie, Sicilian pie, and buffalo are chicken are MUST EAT...More
We have lived in the area for 40 years and have tried most every Pizza in Riverhead and nearby Mattituck. We still prefer the sauce that Lenny uses on all of his Pies. The spice and acidy seems to strike the right balance. The hero's...More
Were were there for New Years Eve. So much food we took some home.Light music in the background (live). We have baked clams for an appetizer, to die for. Lots of clam in the mixture , 4 on the plate, large size. Ht fresh bread...More
Tucked away in a small shopping center Lenny's is great value! Early bird menus is extensive and under $20. Entrees come with a large salad, Lenny's balsamic dressing is very tasty. The home baked bread served warm, and is delicious. Wine prices are very reasonable...More
My wife and I have been here before - once years ago, prior to their renovations in the dining room area, and once last year - but I wanted to leave a positive review after our most recent outing here because of how pleasant our...More
The wild mushroom pizza is to die for. Others are pedestrian. Meals eaten in are good, but certainly not exceptional. Value is reasonable.
Visited Lenny's twice on a recent trip. The pizza was delicious at lunch, but the atmosphere was so much more comfortable in the dining room that evening. Great food; nice people.