The food was good. For a sandwich and beer it was $20. I thought $7 for a draft was high and no happy hour specials.
1 - 10 of 83 reviews
This is an old tavern that is still an inn with 9 rooms. They seem to specialize in burgers, sandwiches, chicken wings and fun beers. The food is always good and the service attentive. Nice funky, dark atmosphere too THEY ARE NOT OPEN FOR LUNCH.
Enjoyed our night at the Inn. Lots of pretty antiques for decor. Ate dinner in the pub. Good food and drinks. The hotel amenities were very nice, right outside our door was coffee, ice, water, glasses, cups. Bathrobes nice since we went down the hall...More
Great atmosphere and we had the chance to sit outside for a nice diner under the late afternoon sun. Great choice of local beers, beverages and food is fine. Service was A+ however only glitch is the noise made by all the truck and bikes...More
Food still good, but old favorites (mine) no longer served. Service needs to be stepped up as it tends to be slow. Great casual place and kids are welcome.
The great meal was nearly ruined by the continuous barrage of loud pickup trucks and motorcycles going through the intersection the restaurant looks out on. We ate in the porch on beautiful summer evening. Too bad the locals don't recognize how annoying this is.
Great atmosphere of a historically renovated Inn with great food and beverages! Their bar is quaint and there is outdoor seating on the 'front porch' and the dining room is warm and friendly.
Thanks much for your good review, We appreciate it very much! We hope to see you again!
Going to the Rogues Harbor Inn is a great choice any day of the week but we really enjoy the Friday night fish fry. The haddock is fried with panko crumbs and is light and delicious. Tonight my meal was served with the vegetable of...More
Thank you so much for enjoying our offerings. We hope you'll return and spread the word!
We live in Rochester NY and drive to Ithaca a few times a year--Rogue's Harbor is right on the way. We have been to the restaurant at least twice before and stayed at the small inn just upstairs once. The inn and restaurant came under...More
We were looking somewhat last minute for a place to throw a happy hour party. These folks pulled out all the stops. We had probably 35 people for which we gave them a 2-week warning, in late November, of our arrival. They rolled out the...More