The food was great, service was great and overall I had a wonderful time. Ooh and the most beautiful sunsets can be seen from the restaurants and the docks
1 - 10 of 65 reviews
My partner took me on a surprise date to Montauk, and we had dinner at Matthew’s Seafood House after mooring our boat at the nearby marina. I was so excited for our romantic trip, but Matthew’s ruined it completely! First, we had incredibly rude wait...More
Fresh seafood and good service by the water. This is not a fancy spot but does well with serving typical northeastern seafood fare. Request a table toward the water for a lovely sunset as you are dining. They also have a nice market in the...More
Sat on the deck overlooking the bay, watching the boaters and jet skis fly by. No noise, just a peaceful relaxing afternoon. The scallops were done to perfection. The grilled tuna was very good. We were not rushed. We sat for over 2 hours and...More
Matthew's is a staple location for dancing and drinking at night in Ocean Beach. It's a great bar, with a sizable outdoor space. Lots of people both inside and out, however, it wasn't too crowded that you couldn't move around. The full bar was great...More
Food was good and the staff were very friendly. Enjoyed being on the water while eating dinner. It turns into a nightclub after 10 pm and stays open until the last guest leaves.
Never had a bad meal here, They do get very busy but the food and view is worth it! Prices are appropriate for Fire Island, I will be going back here.
Dinner for 10 with reservations. Seated,right away,first round of drinks and apps were good. It all,went bad after that. Had to grab server to remind him we had ordered drinks. I had the seafood linguine, it sucked. More than half of the mussels were not...More
Food was good, very nice and good service. Like the views and almost everything was great. The town itself was full of 20 something Year old's, but Matthew's was fantastic. They also sat us quickly and moved us inside when one in our group was...More