We shared only an appetizer at our stop at hte Mettawas Station, but it was delicious and the service was excellent!

You really don't get the sense from the inside that you are eating in an old train station, but it doesn't really matter. I had the Riviera Onion Soup and the Perch and Pickerel main. The Onion Soup will not win awards but there was...nothing wrong with it. the Perch and Pickerel dish however was sublime, with ample servings of both fish (I now know I prefer Perch to Pickerel), potatoes, and vegetables. And the dip that comes with the bread was also very good. Friendly staff dealing with the tribulations of our current times. I would certainly go back, despite it being a bit pricy.More

Atmosphere of eating at a train station was kewl. I saw the last couple reviews and I am a culinary expert. So..... The Sicilian Arancini was excellent, tight risotto balls with a kitchen made a savory sauce. The Rigatoni Arrabbiata was made with Hawaiian peppers!!!...who does that with a Roman sauce in a small town setting, very NICE! Being in the Lake Erie area Perch & Pickerel (walleye for the Americans) are a must if you like damm good fish. Service was knowledge, courteous and the courses came out hot and with no time to waste. Tables have been cut back due to Covid restrictions so, make sure you reserve a table in advance as not to be disappointed. Very good value for a special dining establishment...Best in town.....I think so!More

We shared two pasta dishes and a salad and it was a lot of really tasty food! Prices were reasonable. Service was good. Our only complaint was that there was not enough lighting on the patio and we felt like were eating in the dark...by the end of the night!More

The atmosphere is pleasant, the service courteous, the food not quite perfect. If you are not a culinary expert you probably won't notice their mistakes so you're good to go. They aim to please. Yet we were expecting more.

I ordered dinner online for takeout. With our order I commented that I'd like gravy as there was no option on the online menu. The kitchen staff called to say that we'd have to pay an additional $2. Seeing as I paid via credit card,...I'd asked if it would be ok to simply bring in a toonie and was told that would be fine. When my husband showed up to pick up our food and to pay the additional $2 he had to pay an additional .26 cents (petty but true) even though the food was not ready after an hour wait and then the incredibly rude server demanded that he put on a mask even though he was outside and far away from the people on the patio. We will never go there again. Not even for the annual Christmas party that we've attended for the past 6 years. Bye bye Mettawas.More

Ordered the rack of lamb and filet mignon dinners. Both were delicious, but, oh, the white chocolate and cranberry cheesecake was melt in your mouth Devine.