Only complaint is the noise. The new decor is beautiful but there's nothing to absorb the sound now. But the food is consistently amazing and the service is pretty good.
11 - 20 of 207 reviews
Cost less than I expected and everything was good. Good experience, we will return. We went on first Friday because we weren't able to get into our first choice, we were happy with our choice.
We ate here several years ago and enjoyed it. Food was excellent then. We decided to try it for dinner. This was the first time dining upstairs and it was NOT a good experience. The noise was overwhelming, so much for a quiet relaxing dinner....More
There was parking in pricey parking lots close by but no more free parking on the streets. On Friday night a reservation is a must; especially if you desire a table by the window. My crab cakes were genuine with a minimum of potato. It...More
We like Sunday Brunch because of is culinary variety and delights. Each entree is right-sized for us. It's always well-prepared and well-served. We had Brunch Quiche of the day, Shepherd's Pie, and Cobb Salad with Shrimp. Owner Jean provides great service and owner Tim is...More
Nestled in the heart of downtown Lancaster, PA, this quaint casual / upscale provides a diverse menu, well stocked bar and comfortable atmosphere. Looking for more a more casual experience, eat upstairs. Something more formal, request the basement in a warmer setting that has a...More
The restaurant is located where you can find a few street spots but right next to an open parking lot. We made reservations to ensure we had a table. We arrived and the hostess when she put down her book greeted us. We got to...More
We stopped here for lunch before going to the Fulton Theater, which is very close by. Carr's was very well appointed inside with tables with comfortable chairs and a very large bar sitting area. We both had the specials - a delicious small pizza with...More
We haven't dined here in quite awhile, and the addition of the upstairs is very nice. Our experience was excellent in every way...HIGHLY recommended!
Visiting our daughter in Lancaster for a day and planning to have a nice dinner. She picked Carr's and made a reservation through open table for 4. When we arrived we were kept waiting then told they were booked solid and Open table made a...More
Hello, My Name is Tim Carr owner/chef of Carr's Restaurant. I'm very sorry for the poor reaction to our mistake. Open table is still new to us for reservations made in our upstairs space which is also new to us; we opened this over the...More