It was a wonderful experience. You can share your portions. It’s a great cookie and the owner/ staff are wonderful!
1 - 10 of 211 reviews
At this time of year, this place is only open on the weekends. So, instead of lunch, I had a kids size treat. It's delicious! You pick what type of cookie, which ice cream(s) and which topping(s) that you want. The cookie is warm and...More
First, order your preferred large, flat, dish-like cookie, then your preferred flavor of ice-cream, then a topping. My daughter and I shared a chocolate chip cookie, with 2 scoops of coffee cookies and cream ice-cream, and hot fudge. My son got a peanut butter cookie...More
I have been going to byoc since it first opened and my family and I love this place. Great concept and amazing homemade cookies. It's also great for last minute ice cream cravings when island creamy has an extremely long line and everything about to...More
Was a cute establishment. The cookie itself is very large. It was a bit chewy for my taste which probably due to being microwaved to warm it up. Ice cream is what threw it off. It was very watery and could tell it had been...More
Thank you for taking the time to review BYOC. Two points we'd like to address, first yes our cookies are reheated with the microwave, but we do not feel that makes them chewy. Our cookies are for the most part all soft & most would...More
Highly recommend. We had the fudge cookie with honey roasted peanut butter ice cream covered in hot fudge. It was so decadent and wonderful. I'm ashamed to admit we went back two days in a row.
We loved this place. Went twice while on vacation the week of the pony swim. Everyone kept asking if we preferred the Creamery or Mr. Whippee's, but we preferred this place over both of those!
Build Your Own Cookie is a cool little food truck type vendor with a unique touch. You pick your cookie, your ice cream flavor, and your toppings. I keep it simple and got a cake batter sugar cookie topped with vanilla ice cream, whipped cream,...More
The kids loved build a cookie. Some of my kids are gluten free, and some and dairy free normally, but on this trip I let them choose to be agony if they wanted to try stuff out. They opted to try the cookie ice cream...More