We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The Tripadvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers: Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.
We spent 4 nights in Buckhannon and went to CJ Maggie's 3 times! Food and Service was Great. Friendly Staff and Great Food. We will be back! Great for Solo, Couples, Families and so on. 5 Stars across board! Restaurant and Bathroom were spotless!
April 2, 2021 (Friday) - Visiting daughter, fiance and grandson in Buckhannon. Mid to late afternoon. As we walked in (2 of us) a couple was leaving after eating and bathroom. Nobody before or behind. Hostess finally appeared (3-4 minutes), told us no room and...would be 30 minutes or more. It was not an inviting tone! Left and went down street 1/2 block and ate at Italian Restaurant which was terrific.More
We used to eat at CJ Maggies 20+ years ago when they had a restaurant in Ashland, KY. The Fried Zucchini Strips were just as wonderful as I remembered, lightly breaded and served with a really flavorful honey mustard sauce. The bacon & Cheddar fries...are really good, as is the unsweet and sweet tea. The Sicilian is a really good sandwich that is big enough for sharing.More
They have a massive menu so it’s a perfect place to go to if you got folks who can’t decide what they want. Portion size is large so also a good place to share. Thankfully I saw that while getting seated so we ordered less....Lots of decor and interesting things to see throughout the place.More
very disappointed with Buckhannon's CJMaggies restaurant service today. Wrong food served after waiting an hour then to add insult to injury the Waitress told us that's what we ordered when it wasn't.
The restaurant was not crowded when we arrived.Seated very quickly and placed order...within 10 minutes of being seated.
Then she brought both orders wrong with no frys.
I asked to speak to manager. He came to our table and said what could he do. It was obvious to me "correct the order". We waited another 15 minutes for dinner forgot an order of frys. The frys that were brought with dinner were cold. I could go on but I've never experienced this in Elkins location. Probably won't return to Buckhannon location. Grilled chicken was excellent its a shame they can't get it together.More
My favorite local restaurant so far! Here for a travel nurse contract in Weston. This place serves hearty portions of comfort food in a setting that is warm and welcoming. I love the antiques displayed and worked into the environment. Food has been great! Be...sure to get a potato yacht and their Mac and cheese as sides. Yum!More
This is a nice restaurant. They seem to be taking COVID seriously. We ordered Chicken Alfredo and a Greek pizza to go. My son enjoyed the chicken dish and the Greek pizza was wonderful. While we waited at the bar for our food - the...seats were appropriate spaced - we sampled some really good craft beer. I wish I could remember the name of it - the bartender recommended it. If you are in Buckhannon, I highly recommend this place.More
This was the best restaurant we’ve been to in a while. The food was great and I liked the atmosphere. I had a calzone which was delicious. My husband had a steak and potato yacht (deep fried potato skin filled with mashed potatoes and cheese)....His steak was perfect and he really liked the potato. Their menu is huge! Service was great also!More
Date of visit: February 2020
Jet54059282151, Owner at C.J. Maggie's, responded to this reviewResponded February 17, 2020
lisadA5915WR, thank you! We are delighted you and your husband both enjoyed our delicious food and welcoming atmosphere. We put our guests’ experiences and satisfaction as our priority. Your positive review reaffirms the hard work and dedication we put into ensuring our guests enjoy excellent...More
I have patronized this business for years. Food and service have been hit or miss, but now I will highly recommend everyone to support based on the exceptional service a young lady named Lillah provided. She was highly knowledgeable, courteous and exceptional at the service...she provided! Food came out as requested with the quickest service I’ve ever received and it was on a very busy Friday night! Lillah I’ll verify you’re on staff prior to every time we visit!More
Date of visit: February 2020
Jet54059282151, Owner at C.J. Maggie's, responded to this reviewResponded February 9, 2020
Deanfam4, we are so appreciative of your excellent rating and review. We are so pleased that your visit was outstanding. We will be sure to let Lillah and the rest of the team know how much their service was appreciated. We thank you for mentioning...More