I have tried several dishes and have enjoyed them all. I am enjoying the McKinley and pimento cheese fries! Relish!
1 - 10 of 461 reviews
This is a must stop. Parking is wherever you can find it. Put your name in and then set upstairs in the bar/sitting area while you wait. Every specialty sandwich looked excellent and sounded awesome. The appetizer, Pimento Cheese Fries are a MUST. Gluten Free...More
I had no idea this place was even here. We stumbled upon Fayetteville while visiting the New River Gorge Bridge. Such a cool town. This place caught our eye so we decided to dine here. Great food, beer, and atmosphere.
Arrived around 1:30 pm. Had 20-30 minutes to wait but enjoyed the upstairs bar which served beer, hard cider and cold drinks. Lunch was delicious! Turkey, peach jam, onions and bleu cheese on a roll was really good. As was the meatloaf sandwich-all named after...More
I was leading a group of 20 geologists through WV and had SSS in mind for lunch stop. I called around 10:00am on a Wednesday to give heads up that our group was coming. They don't take reservations but staff mentally reserved a bunch of...More
We stopped for a quick bite before heading back to Michigan and we wished we had discovered it sooner. The food was excellent. My husband had the meatloaf sandwich and I had the Eisenhower. We couldn't miss out on the loaded fries which were my...More
I guess reading glowing reviews on TripAdvisor can set you up for disappointment. We had an hour and a half wait for the tiny sandwich joint. There is no ambience whatsoever, with the cleaver name, high ratings and dedicated patrons I expected something more to...More
A different touch to some popular sandwiches. They named the sandwiches after presidents and first ladies. very good food and service! i was not too thrilled when when my family elected to go here after eating Subway and JJs the days preceding but i was...More
Our sandwiches came with homemade chips. Good. The ketchup, however, tasted like tomato paste. My sandwich was good, on a lovely crusty roll. Good beer/wine/cider selection. We ate on the porch. Moderate portions, we had room for keylime pie.
We loved this place and would happily go here again. Th atmosphere was wonderful and food was great. If you like unique sandwiches (along with more regular sandwiches) you will enjoy.