Now I must honestly admit! This is some of the best pizza I have ever eaten. Would recommend to anyone!
1 - 10 of 67 reviews
Come hungry, leave satisfied. The hamburgers are HUGE and GOOD! The pizza is LOADED. Order a smaller size than you normally would. As an example, the sausage on the pizza is the size of meatballs. Check for hours. They seem to change occasionally.
Best pizza in town hands down. Thick crust, fresh ingredients and good service. Nice place to call ahead and carry out or dine in for a casual atmosphere.
The pizza was pretty bad-- the very thick crust overwhelmed the toppings (which were good), seemed more like pizza bread. And the crust was flavorless, we recommend they brush garlic olive oil along the edges to give the pizza a much needed boost. Would definitely...More
Pizza is really good, they pile on the toppings, thick or thin crust, very reasonable prices, friendly staff. This is more of a bar type atmosphere later in the evening, so it can be loud, which is fine with me.
After eating dinner nearby I stopped in around 6 pm on a Saturday for a drink. The place was packed and everyone was having a great time. I just had Maker's on the rocks, very reasonably priced at $6. Fun atmosphere, college hoops on the...More
Gem City is our favorite restaurant in Baraboo. I could rave about the pizza all day which is generously loaded in all categories (cheese, toppings, sauce) and also at a great price. Everything else on the menu is this way as well, excellent quality- like...More
First visit was a nice experience. Met some friends, had a couple drinks and a pizza. Handmade medium thickness but not heavy. The toppings are generously applied, especially the sausage, what is served in big chunks. Drinks were good, referring to brandy old fashion and...More