If you want the BEST pies in the Midwest - do not miss the Pie Co. From every type of berry to key lime - these pies are fresh and flavorful! Strawberry rhubarb crumble will bring you back over and over again! BOOM!
1 - 10 of 92 reviews
I've had several pies from Lake Geneva Pie Company....The banana cream is too die for...I've also had several fruit pies that were very good....The pies were always fresh.....
Been here many times love the pies,quiche best in area.good soup sandwich spot. Also good cookies coffee. Friendly people. Amazing bakers.
Always come here for a piece of pie when I'm in town, never disappointed, today I had raspberry blackraspberry, very good. Nice variety every time. Quiche and sandwiches are fresh and look great. Soup and salads too. The coffee was not so good.
I love this place. They have delicious fresh baked pies every day. My favorite is the banana cream but the Cherry is also good. I recommend just buying a whole pie for everyone to share! Be sure to eat the banana cream the same day...More
Pleasant drive from Chicago takes us through Richmond, IL. (antiques and specialty shops) Just a few more miles on Rt. 12 to Lake Geneva. The Lake Geneva Pie Company makes all their pies and cookies from scratch. DELICIOUS!! AMAZING!! Very much worth the drive. You...More
The pie company sells pies by the SLICE. We asked for a SLICE of apple pie and were told we couldn't have it because none were cut. Yet there were many apple pies in the case...go figure! We could have a complete small pie by...More