OMG the Ahi Tuna is to die for!! In a steak house!! Awesome I have not had such a melt in the month tuna since Costa Rica last year!! Oh and the Louis Steak (did have a bite of my husbands) is butter in your...More
1 - 10 of 138 reviews
Please read, especially if you are looking to go during a weekend or holiday. Me, my wife, my sister and brother in law, and their child went to the Butler Inn on New Year's Eve after making a reservation for 530pm. Upon arrival, I was...More
Decent food, seems the steaks are their signature dish. Fried chicken was battered well, but dry inside. Two of our guests said the same thing. Service was pleasant and helpful. Decor was older style but nicely kept. Would return when in town again.
There was hardly anyone here on a Friday night. We had an awesome waitress, who suggested great entrees! The menu is over priced , especially for Pewaukee!
The Louie’s five star is the way to go! Super tender, flavorful steak. They could improve on their appetizer selection and sides, but I still give them a five star rating because the steak trumps anything else out there. A little updating in the restaurant...More
We love the Butler Inn. Mainly because the Louis 5 Star Signature Steak is the finest we've had. Recently made our annual visit for our anniversary. Steaks are perfectly prepared. Tender and flavorful! The servers are friendly and engaging. We made reservations, letting them know...More
Eight friends meet regularly for dinners out. We went to The Butler Inn. Seated immediately. Nice crowd present. Bonnie, our waitress was terrific. A complimentary cocktail for our anniversary was great. Rib eye steaks for many. But, some had the rib eye sandwiches. They were...More
I surprised my wife along with another couple for my wife's 60th Birthday. We all ordered steaks & everything was EXCELLENT!!! We will be back! The Old Saying is TRUE--- YOU GET WHAT YOU PAY FOR! And the Molten Chocolate Cake is too die for!
Service was friendly and quite good although rushed. I was served my soup before I took a second sip of my cocktail. My drink, a whiskey old fashioned, was certainly not muddled and probably prepared with a pre-mix along with a dash of whiskey. No...More
Had Louie's Steak and it was perfectly done. Excellent food. Exceptional service. This is a fine restaurant.