Made the mistake of going to Ship Wheel, save yourself the time and come here instead. Great and fast service! Owner was really nice, great prices and amazing pizza!
1 - 10 of 36 reviews
After enjoying the island, doing some fly fishing, and some photo ops we stopped by for some pizza. The staff was great. Pizza came out quick, great seating. We have leftovers too! Bring cash or a check. Would definitely come back. Right by the ferry...More
caught a quick slice and a soda for lunch while on a break from a charter fishing trip when we didn't bring anything for lunch. Surprised by the choices and quality.
We were fishing and called ahead to be able to pick up pizza when done. We like a nice thin crust. This pizza was excellent - thin crust, great sauce, hot and on time. Very friendly owner. If this place was local, I would order...More
Great initial impression, sales-pep-talking, but average mediocre food. The guy behind the counter gives you a "fresh hot just out the oven pizza", you sit there chilling for the next 30 min listening same story all over. It is still that same "just out of...More
We had a few hours to kill upon arrival to the Island and before the Cherry Train departed for our tour. We were honestly skeptical as we are pizza aficionados - but were we ever glad that Dan the Pizza Man convinced us to try...More
When we arrived to the island we were starving. After renting bikes, we rode to Island Pizza. They sell pizza by the slice and also offer other items. We got three HUGE slices of hot pizza and a bag of chicken tenders and fries. The...More
This should be a stop if you are in the area. The staff/owner are great and the food is great. One of the best pizzas I have had in a long time.
This quaint stop is to your left as soon as you land on the island and has some very good pizza! It comes out hot and with the best crust I have had in years with plenty of well seasoned toppings. The owner is a...More