All three of us enjoyed our food. It was all good, even the special drink of the day, an Old Fashion with a twist!
11 - 20 of 131 reviews
1st time there Great service Menu changes often Salmon and mashed potatoes were excellent Pasta dish was as well Great setting in small store front feel Worth the stop
As we entered we were warmly greeted & escorted to our table. There was a display of the works of local artists hanging on the cream city brick walls illuminated by the light of the ceiling high windows. We have been here several times &...More
A cute, cozy little place. Nicely decorated historic looking pub. Server very nice, courteous, and informative. Food very good
My husband and I were traveling through Wisconsin and took a break in Whitewater for dinner. I specifically chose Black Sheep because of the farm connection as I am a farm girl and I know good food. I also identify with a solid work ethic...More
One of my favorite restaurants to visit in Whitewater. The food is absolutely wonderful. Awesome choices and different varieties. Also, very nice to have a restaurant that is willing to accommodate vegan and gluten-free needs. Two thumbs up for this lovely restaurant.
I can not say enough good things about our recent dinner at The Black Sheep. We were greeted warmly by all staff. The bartender was friendly and engaging; she made several drink recommendations and was very knowledgable about the liquors and drinks. The Old-Fashioned of...More
I love the idea of farm to table, locally grown but all I will say is: it was Saturday night at 6:00 and the place was barely half full and we had a hair in our food. Not on my must return list.
Very pleased - cute inside (except our table needed adjustment but we fixed that!) Food was VERY good and service friendly. Meatloaf was great and the others had the chicken piccatta - we are all very happy. The beet & kale dip was just okay....More
Food was outstanding! Unique choices and food combinations at this farm-to-table restaurant. Cocktails were excellent as well. They have an "old-fashioned of the month" as well. Definitely not a place if you are a picky eater or only want chicken strips and fries. Service, however,...More