My boyfriend and I came to Maggie's after our first day out and about in Bayfield. After hearing about how great their food was as well as how fun their atmosphere is, we decided to try it. Boy do we regret it. I ordered the...More
1 - 10 of 666 reviews
If you want to check out some place with quirky interior decor with a certain atmosphere, check this place out. As for the food, it was average, and everything was over-seasoned, in my opinion. The spicy chicken is definitely a must try if you love...More
We went there for dinner after a long and rainy day of kayaking. There was a wait but it wasn't long. The entire process of being seated, having our orders taken, and getting our food wasn't too long either. I had the shrimp scampi and...More
Until today, I had nothing but really fond memories of Maggie's. I consider it a 'must do' when visiting Bayfield. Today I chose the chipotle black bean burger. It looked great served on a yellow Fiesta Ware plate. I chose to upgrade to the hand-cut...More
Had dinner there last night - took half home as it was a big portion, and delicious as dinner, and then as lunch today. Always good sized portions and good price for what you get.
I enjoyed special lunch - whitefish sandwich. The fish was excellent & waitress was efficient, helpful & pleasant. Funky but fun decor - lots of flamingos & bright colors. All sides were tasty & fresh. It is a few blocks away from popular eating places...More
Very good food, but wish there were more gluten free and vegetarian options. Had the gluten free pizza - good crust, good pizza, but not outstanding.
Decor is a bit on the loud and tacky side, but the food is good. Prices are fair, as well. Be prepared to wait for a table, and there isn't much room between tables (you will most likely feel cramped). Server provided good service. Bathroom...More
This has always been a favorite stop for us when we are in Bayfield. We both had individual pizzas this time and they were absolutely delicious.
If you love flamingo's or want a kitschy place this is it! Friendly relaxed environment. The food was very decent portion sized if not large...great tasting..good prices...We went for dinner and lunch while in Bayfield...if you dare... try the Whitefish livers..and the unique flavors of...More