Bought a strawberry-rhubarb pie right out of the oven. Delicious. One of the best crusts I've ever had.
1 - 10 of 48 reviews
Stopped in while hiking the Brownstone trail and got two pastries. They were both amazing. The cheese danish was warm and you couldn't dream of a better tasting cheese danish. Wow! I don't remember any place to sit and eat, so I think it's a...More
They were in the process of making apple pies. We ordered one and picked it up 30 minutes later. Warm, right out of the oven. It was absolutely wonderful. The two of us wolfed down half the pie in no time. The service was great...More
Had read about the pies somewhere and figured we needed to try them. The first day I stopped, it was around 11 and almost all the pies were gone. But they had some interesting looking turnovers. Bought those, and that was definitly a good call....More
Gourmet Garage is right off of the scenic byway headed into downtown Bayfield. I stopped in right away in the morning to buy some breakfast. I purchased one apple turnover and one raspberry turnover, and both were delicious and a great price too!
The Gourmet Garage is always our first stop coming into town and our last stop leaving town, most times we stop every day to load up on the cookies, turnovers and danish!
Was within walking distance and walked there numerous times. Get there early as during busy season may not get best of the picks.
We were looking for an afternoon picnic snack for taking to a park. We saw this and figured "Why not pie?". What a surprise! Great pie, outstanding pastries, and a good story too! If you're in Bayfield, stop here!
Ok, so let me start off by saying this Gourmet Garage is a hoot! It's family owned and 26 years old and going strong. Everything is good here but let me tell you she's famous for her pies! Oh and I forgot to mention that...More
When you are travelling northern Wisconsin, be sure to visit Bayfield...and while in Bayfield, be sure to stop at a non-pretentious little hideway called Judy's Gourmet Garage. Tucked onto one end of a residence, this bakery is not fussy or fancy, and it's small...it almost...More