¡WOW! Rally delicious, such big portions that anything you choose from the Menu will be more than enough for 2 or 3 people. We had lasgna and parmagiana chicken and I highly suggest you eat any of those.
1 - 10 of 5,396 reviews
We returned to Carmine's again after trying other places in Time Square to find the service incredible, food outstanding and an electric atmosphere! True, there maybe tourists, but the experience has always been rewarding and we enjoy the vibrancy of the entire restaurant! We hit...More
It’s loud, it’s raucous, it’s crowded, you’ll probably wait, but you’ll love it. We were two couples and made the last minute decision to head to Carmine’s, so our only real option was to go early, at 5:00 pm. The restaurant was already bustling but...More
The food and drinks are great! The portions are generous, for 2 or even 3 people. It is better to make a reservation because there is always a waiting list.
Went to carmines to celebrate my daughters birthday! Very busy, but food and service was awesome! We got a heads up from friends to make a reservation before we left for New York. Thank goodness we did. When we went, they were not taking anymore...More
The title of this review tells it all, crowded, noisy, expensive , fair food. Stay away at all cost. If you are looking for a similar restaurant try Tony Di Napolis, a much better choice.
The food was wonderful. Well-prepared and fresh with huge portions. We had a large party in town for business and the service was on point.
The finest meal in New York. We had the Carmine’s famous meatballs, chicken parm and the excellent country style rigatoni with sausage which is the best.As usual the host, waiters and all of the staff are on their game.We can’t wait to go back.Compliments to...More
Carmine's is vastly overrated. The place is over crowded and very commercialized. They serve HUGE portions of very basic american italian food that is fair. So if you want to share huge portions of marginal food, this place is for you. If you have a...More