Place was cozy and jazzy, good music and atmosphere. Both the food and service was OK. Maybe a bit too expensive compared to the quality.
1 - 10 of 73 reviews
I am so happy that I chose this restaurant to celebrate my birthday. The food and drinks were so good. The owner and waitress were so personable and sincerely pleasant that I felt like I was eating dinner at home with family and friends. I...More
We needed a place for a pre-theater dinner in the West Village of NYC. It was by happenstance that we stopped at Gaetana's; it was along the walking route from where we parked to the theater that was our destination. We entered with a bit...More
A friend suggested we eat here before a play at the IRT Theatre, an experimental theatre diagonally across from Gaetana's. At 5 pm the place was mostly empty, and we had great service. It's got a lot of atmosphere and lots of dark wood. The...More
Visited for the first time, and were more than pleasantly rewarded with delicious scampi, linguine with clams and lobster ravioli, not to mention the warmest welcome from Frankie and his staff. Frankie is everyone's favorite uncle, it really is a hidden gem in the city,...More
This was the best eating place we visited during all of our NYC trip. From beginning to end a superlative experience in this comfortable, charming, clean and welcoming restaurant (gay friendly). Our waitress was most welcoming and charming and was really interested in delivering a...More
It looked good on Trip Advisor. Cute. Cozy. Close to my daughter's dorm. Perfect! And it was exactly that! The waitress, was the real deal Italian, and was charming and helpful. We shared the fried calamari and a stuffed artichoke for appetizers. The latter was...More