I order Anderson's through skip the dishes a lot. The food is average. The homemade ice cream is out of this world.
Is this restaurant good for dining on a budget?
Is this a fast food place?
Is this restaurant appropriate for Kids?
Is this restaurant wheelchair accessible?
Is this restaurant good for dinner?
Is this restaurant good for lunch?
Is this a dessert shop?
Are the prices at this restaurant low or inexpensive?
Is this restaurant good for brunch?
Can a vegetarian person get a good meal at this restaurant?
Thanks for helping!Share another experience before you go.
Stopped in for beef on weck and beef on multiseeded roll. Plus frozen yogurt and ice cream. Bright interior, friendly counter service. Caters to families with kids. Roast beef was excellent. Mango apricot yogurt good, sponge cake ice cream too sweet.
Ok, I'm predjudiced, no custard is as good as the custard in Rochester, NY at Read's or Abbott's but Anderson's comes in the top 3! I highly recommend it when in the Buffalo area. It is like tradition to go for custard at Anderson's!!!
Probably one of the most delightful sandwiches I have ever stood in line for. I would do it again. The only reason this restaurant does not get a 5 is because it is self serve. The rolls are chewy but tender and the meat is sliced paper thin and melts in your mouth. The horseradish tops off the flavor profile.
Every time I go back to Buffalo to visit family I stop here. Love the flavors of the day, especially cinnamon .
This place has amazing roast beef sandwiches but it's all about the frozen custard. The beef sandwich was great. Lots of beef. Get it on the "salted roll". And add horseradish. Do not leave without getting a frozen custard cone. While there are options, get the vanilla/chocolate twist. Perfection!
I had never had frozen custard and am now wanting it in the southern part of the state! it was smooth creaminess for sure! They do also have sandwich and burger options too, but the star here is the custard.
Love the curley fries here! They have a lot of sandwich options and soups as well. The beef on weck is very good but nothing compared to Charley the Butchers. Desserts are always amazing!
Standing in line at Anderson's provides opportunities to see friends and neighbors. Creamy soft serve, freezer treats to take home are expected, but good roast beef, turkey, fries, hot dogs and burgers are never a disappointment. Follow the locals and ask for Susie at Union Road- she's the best!
If you've never had frozen custard, hurry up and go to Anderson's! The smooth creaminess of their frozen custard will make your eye roll back in your head, it's so good! The location on Sheridan Drive have a 1950s vibe--you walk up to the window to order your delicacy. The also have other treats: ice cream, sandwiches, etc. but I... More
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.Claim Your Listing