Amazing pizza, questionable Covid protocols. Stopped in a couple of days ago for a slice and the dining area was closed off, good, but there were 3 visible staff including the cashier and not a mask in sight, not good. The staff here is super...nice and the food is great but whoever’s in charge should maybe be ensuring all lockdown protocols are being followed.More

Delicious flavour and fresh toppings. I had never been before but was driving by and saw ‘stone baked pizza by the slice’ and couldn’t drive past. I tried one of their best sellers, the Chicken Caesar. The flavour was amazing but I have to be...careful and it was a bit too rich for me so I wasn’t able to finish it all. (The cheeseburger pizza looked incredible, unfortunately I don’t eat beef ☹️) The crust was the best though!! I would love to try another specialty pizza, they offer such unique pairings! Will definitely go back.More

We were staying at the nearby B-W Hotel and thought we'd do 'take-out' because of the Covid virus. These won't be the cheapest pizzas you've ever eaten, but they might be the best. Fresh ingredients properly prepared by skilled chefs. Excellent.

The staff was awesome, very polite Food was amazing. When we go through to visit our friend outside of walkerton, we must always stop to either get a slice or a full pizza. Love the different selections

A few months ago I was in town for work and didn't get a chance to try this place so when coming home from Christmas up north we detoured here! Good decision for sure. Staff was friendly, place is clean and I loved the decor!...We got the Canadian 12" pizza. Two of us ate the whole thing. Loved how they hide all the ingredients under the cheese. Wished the bacon was crispy though but otherwise the sauce wasn't spicy and everything had such great flavour! If we ever near the area again we will be trying one of their other flavours of pizza. Pulled pork sounded really good too!More

My family loves pizza and decided to try here as it was recommended by a co worker. So glad we did. It was delicious and will def drive the 1/2 hr to get it again. My new favourite pizza joint!!! You’ll be seeing me again.

Since returning to Bruce County almost a year ago, I've been asking people where you can get a great pizza. The answer 8 times out of 10 is The Old Garage, and finally had a chance to taste for myself on a Saturday night driving...home from a hockey tournament. My travelling mates and I picked up three large pies to go. My Twisted Chicken was simply sensational - lots of chicken, garlic, spinach, bacon and tomato on a perfectly cooked thin crust. The bacon cheeseburger pizza also smelled unbelievably good and I can't wait to try that one. Our pizzas were ready when we arrived to pick them up, and were piping hot. I look forward to going back and sitting down for a meal.More

The wood fire makes a big difference. (OK the best I have had was done in a coal fired oven, not in Canada) In the past few years we have stopped going to the other pizza places in town as this one give very fast...turn around on take out orders, and has some very interesting pizzas.More

Awesome pie with an awesome date. She got a Fanta and I a Stewart. Great lunch date. Hawaiian (yes pineapple is a real topping) was great. The 2x2 Pep was crazy. I’ve never seen so much pepperoni on a pizza!

I live two towns over and for a special treat I will drive the distance past many pizza places to get their pizza. However, yesterday's experience was not what I was so looking forward to. It was lunch time and they were very busy, as...I've found the norm to be there. I wasn't too concerned when it took a little longer than usual. Driving home with it in the back of my vehicle, I wasn't too far out of Walkerton when I started to smell "burnt toast ". Unfortunately, it was way over cooked with black spots on the bottom. And, I had ordered olive oil to be drizzled over it after it was cooked...and that did not appear to have happened either. It was not pleasant to eat, and the leftover pieces that I enjoy heating up the next day were tossed out. I suppose I should have pulled over and checked when I was driving, but I was on the highway and it was busy. I wish they had noticed, I would have waited for them to redo it. Had this been my first time there, I'm sure I would never return given the distance I go for it. I'm hoping I will get past this, I know this is not the norm for them, but, I will be checking next time and " requesting" when ordering that it not be over cooked.More

I travel around the world and this is one of the greatest pizza's I've ever had. Great taste, good juicy and a fantastic tastefully crust. If you like pizza this is a must visit if you are in the area.

Over rated and over priced, very nice staff. I've tried stone oven before, this left much to be desired, I'd rate it a 7 out of ten at best.