We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Italian Restaurants in Fire Island

View map
Map
Satellite
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
Your SelectionsClear all
(24)
Cuisines & Dishes
(36)
(24)
(7)
Bar
(38)
Brew Pub
(1)
(4)
Contemporary
(1)
Diner
(4)
(5)
Grill
(1)
(2)
(1)
(18)
Pub
(23)
(5)
Southwestern
(2)
(7)
(1)
Burrito
(3)
Cheesecake
(3)
Corned Beef
(1)
Crab
(8)
Filet Mignon
(4)
Fish & Chips
(1)
Hamburger
(16)
Lasagne
(1)
Lobster
(15)
Lobster Roll
(9)
Omelette
(1)
Oyster
(8)
Paella
(2)
Pasta
(1)
Ribs
(2)
Shrimp
(32)
Souvlaki
(1)
Tapas
(1)
More
Meals
(20)
(25)
Price
Cheap Eats
(9)
Mid-range
(34)
Fine Dining
(2)
Restaurant features
Free Wifi
(1)
Parking Available
(5)
Reservations
(10)
Serves Alcohol
(10)
Takeout
(14)
Wheelchair Accessible
(12)
More
Good for
Bar Scene
(2)
Business meetings
(2)
(4)
Kids
(5)
More
Sort by:
  • Relevance
  • Ranking
  • Name
We found great results, but some are outside Fire Island. Showing results within 40 km of Fire Island.
Limit search to Fire Island.
Town Pizza Ocean Beach
#2 of 28 Results
$ Pizza
#3 of 28 Results
$ Pizza Italian
#4 of 28 Results
$$$$ American
Vinnie's Mulberry Street East Islip 10.1 km away
#6 of 28 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Pizza
La Tavola Sayville 11.0 km away
#7 of 28 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Gluten Free Options
Reserve
Verace Islip 10.7 km away
#8 of 28 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Gluten Free Options
Reserve
Mannino's Oakdale 10.6 km away
#9 of 28 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Gluten Free Options
Francesco's Trattoria East Islip 10.0 km away
#10 of 28 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Pizza
Butera's Sayville 11.3 km away
#11 of 28 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Gluten Free Options
Reserve
A S Italian Fine Foods East Islip 10.1 km away
#12 of 28 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Seafood
Original Mama's Oakdale 9.9 km away
#13 of 28 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Pizza Seafood
Vinnies Mulberry Street East Islip 10.0 km away
#14 of 28 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Pizza
Fargiano's Pizza and Pasta East Islip 10.0 km away
#15 of 28 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Pizza
Sal's Pizza Sayville 11.0 km away
#16 of 28 Results
Mama's Italian Restaurant Oakdale 10.7 km away
#17 of 28 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Pizza
Seacrest Sayville Diner Sayville 10.8 km away
#18 of 28 Results
$$ - $$$ Diner
Gio's Pizzeria East Islip 11.0 km away
#19 of 28 Results
$ Italian Pizza
#20 of 28 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian
Angela's Pizzeria Islip 11.3 km away
#21 of 28 Results
$ Italian Pizza
The Pie at Salvatores Bay Shore 11.8 km away
#22 of 28 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Pizza
Pizza Parm Islip 10.7 km away
#23 of 28 Results
$ Italian Pizza
#24 of 28 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Pizza
Sayville Pizza Sayville 11.2 km away
#25 of 28 Results
$ Pizza Italian
Fratelli Pizzeria Bay Shore 11.5 km away
#26 of 28 Results
$ Italian Pizza
Aria Melanie On The Lake Bay Shore 12.0 km away
#27 of 28 Results
Reserve
Ralphs Italian Ices Bay Shore 11.9 km away
#28 of 28 Results
$ Italian