We noticed that you're using an unsupported browser. The TripAdvisor website may not display properly.We support the following browsers:
Windows: Internet Explorer, Mozilla Firefox, Google Chrome. Mac: Safari.

Seafood Restaurants in Shelter Island

View map
Map
Satellite
Map updates are paused. Zoom in to see updated info.
Reset zoom
Updating Map...
Your SelectionsClear all
(39)
Reservations
Online Bookings
Cuisines & Dishes
(39)
(17)
(4)
Bar
(25)
Cantonese
(1)
Central American
(1)
Contemporary
(2)
Diner
(3)
(4)
(1)
Gastropub
(1)
(1)
Grill
(2)
(14)
(3)
(8)
Pub
(18)
(5)
Southwestern
(1)
(3)
Szechuan
(1)
Bagels
(1)
Baguette
(3)
Burrito
(5)
Ceviche
(3)
Cheesecake
(1)
Chowder
(1)
Corned Beef
(1)
Crab
(19)
Crab Cake
(8)
Falafel
(1)
Filet Mignon
(4)
Fish & Chips
(7)
French Toast
(1)
Frozen Yogurt
(1)
Gyros
(1)
Halloumi
(1)
Hamburger
(38)
Lasagne
(1)
Lobster
(29)
Lobster Roll
(23)
Omelette
(5)
Oyster
(22)
Pasta
(1)
Polenta
(2)
Porterhouse Steak
(1)
Ribs
(5)
Sandwiches
(2)
Shrimp
(37)
Souvlaki
(1)
Tapas
(1)
Tortillas
(1)
More
Dietary Restrictions
Meals
(8)
(29)
(34)
Price
Mid-range
(64)
Fine Dining
(4)
Restaurant features
Accepts Credit Cards
(12)
Free Wifi
(13)
Parking Available
(19)
Reservations
(25)
Serves Alcohol
(29)
Takeout
(19)
Television
(12)
Wheelchair Accessible
(25)
More
Good for
Bar Scene
(19)
(11)
Kids
(16)
Local cuisine
(7)
(8)
More
Sort by:
  • Relevance
  • Ranking
  • Name
We found great results, but some are outside Shelter Island. Showing results within 40 km of Shelter Island.
Limit search to Shelter Island.
#3 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ American Seafood Gluten Free Options
Little Creek Oyster Farm & Market Greenport, NY 5.3 km away
#4 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ American Seafood Gluten Free Options
Claudio's Restaurant Greenport, NY 5.3 km away
#6 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ American Seafood Soups
PORT Waterfront Bar and Grill Greenport, NY 5.3 km away
#7 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ American Bar Seafood Pub
Crabby Jerry's Greenport, NY 5.2 km away
#9 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ American Bar Seafood Pub
Claudio's Clam Bar Greenport, NY 5.2 km away
#10 of 39 Results
American Bar Seafood Pub
Billy's By The Bay Greenport, NY 5.9 km away
#11 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ American Bar Seafood
Noah's Greenport, NY 5.4 km away
#12 of 39 Results
Reserve
Sunset Beach Shelter Island Heights
#13 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ French American Bar Seafood
Dock House Sag Harbor 7.0 km away
#14 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ American Seafood Soups
Dory Shelter Island Heights
#15 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ American Bar Seafood Pub
Barba Bianca Greenport, NY 5.2 km away
#16 of 39 Results
$$$$ Seafood Italian
A Lure Southold, NY 6.7 km away
#17 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ American Seafood Gluten Free Options
The Bell & Anchor Sag Harbor 7.9 km away
#18 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ American Seafood
Reserve
Reserve
Porto Bello Greenport, NY 6.2 km away
#20 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ Italian Seafood
Reserve
Sen Sag Harbor 7.2 km away
#23 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ Japanese Seafood Sushi Asian
Deep Water Bar and Grille Greenport, NY 5.3 km away
#24 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ Seafood American Bar Grill Pub Vegetarian Friendly
Bay Kitchen Bar East Hampton 12.8 km away
#26 of 39 Results
#27 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ American Seafood Bar Pub
The Halyard Greenport, NY 7.1 km away
#28 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ Seafood American
Reserve
Reserve
Harbor Bistro East Hampton 13.2 km away
#30 of 39 Results
$$ - $$$ American Seafood