I'm so undecided it's nuts! I went to roatan last year. Had a nice place to stay, great diving company to dive with but not sure what to do. Roatan good snorkeling in front of my place, diving hoping we'll find better dive spots. I like to be able to listen to a band or go out to dinner easily (relative).
I like the idea about utila being a little more remote and do it yourself type of feel.
I want to experience the best snorkeling/diving possible. I would like to see the whale sharks over in utila and we'll be there during the full moon time frame.
Going dec 26-jan 3.