My husband and I dined at the Club Car last week with another couple and it was hands down our fave meal of the trip (we also had dinners at Galley Beach, Nautilus, and Proprieters, to name a few). I make a mean Bee’s Knees cocktail at home, but the one served here was next level good. Do yourself a favor and order the bravette steak on the land and sea portion of the menu. It was the yummiest cut of meat I have ever had. The meal was pricey, but typical of Nantucket dinners (I think we spent around $350 for 4 of us, but I think we each had 2 cocktails.) Dinner felt very relaxed- they were constantly bringing out more food (tapas style) for us to savor. We missed the piano bar in favor of a trip to the Chicken Box, but we will be back for sure!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.