My partner and I got married in Key West and chose The Mermaid & The Alligator as our place to stay. We'd never stayed in a B&B before and we feel like M&A set the bar really high! We stayed in the Caribbean Queen room and just like the rest of the house/grounds, it was beautiful, well-decorated, and just made us feel special.
We stayed several days and got to interact with with Geri, Victor, and Rebecca and they were all so accommodating and friendly that they really helped make our trip feel special. We also got to see several rooms, each with its own personality. No matter where they were in the house, they all felt private and secluded.
Don't skip the breakfast! It was some of the best food we had during our trip, and eating in the garden is such a peaceful and relaxing way to start your day.
The whole place felt special. We can't wait to visit again. This may be our new go-to place in Key West.More