Our family (three generations) wanted a place in Islamorada with 5 bedrooms. We rented the Osprey Bay Villa for a week and it was a perfect fit. The bay side location provided spectacular views of the sunset, the dock was great for docking our rental boat and for light tackle fishing, and a short walk up the drive to Overseas Highway took us to the Bayside Gourmet restaurant (TripAdvisor's top rated restaurant in Islamorada). And yes, there are Osprey, with several of the magnificent birds in residence atop their elevated nest.
Add the pool and hot tub, a kitchen with two sinks, three refrigerators (one for food as you would expect, plus one for the bar, and one for fish bait and whatever you brought back from your fishing excursions). You get the idea - the setting and the house were ideal. We are planning on a return visit next year. I would recommend Osprey Bay for any family or small group of friends wanting a beautiful vacation place in the Keys.
After 10 years of going to islamorada this is the best all round rental house for location, boating and quality. We have rented 7 different properties and this has it all