We just got home from our first trip to Disney World and our first stay at the Art of Animation Hotel. Honestly, I had pretty low expectations going into our stay, as we opted for a "value" hotel and because it was themed. BUT, I was pleasantly surprised throughout our stay. The hotel is clean and well-kept. They did a great job with the different themes and large character statues throughout the resort. There are several different pools, which makes it easy to swim and cool off, even if you aren't staying in the main building. The main pool is really fun with a splash pad and lots of chairs and tables to sit at. The life gaurds were super nice and also really diligent about keeping an eye on all of the little swimmers. There is a bar close to the main pool and although there's no one to bring you drinks, it's nice to have a pina colada so close. They are constantly doing different activities around the pool area for the kids throughout the day: trivia, hula-hooping contests, music and of course there is the nightly Disney movie under the stars every single night. There is one restaurant choice at the hotel which is a cafeteria type set-up. The food is okay and expensive but I will say that they have a large variety of things to choose from (at any meal) to accomodate everyone's tastes. They also seemed pretty lax on outside food and drinks so it was nice to be able to bring down a bag of our snacks to the pool.
Although we never took advantage of it, the late-night pizza delivery would be so great for those long nights when you just want to stay in the room and have a late-night snack. The shuttle service to the park was so wonderful to have and it was also amazing to be able to take advantage of the magic hours. The magic band also makes it very easy to not have to lug around any extra stuff (i.e. a wallet or a room key) and also makes it easy to make purchases at the parks and at the hotel. So, in a nutshell, the hotel isn't fancy but the kids LOVED it and we loved that we still felt like we got to stay in a nice resort with the nice resort price tag. We would definitely recommend!