Suprised to read some poor reviews, that was not our experience at Kelly's. They seated us (table for 4) even though they were serving an employee's wedding reception that night. Our waiter was very attentive and our meal came quickly. We later found out the waiter had been working for a 12 hour shift due to a catered event earlier but he did not give us an impression of being tired or anxious to go home. My scallops were the best I have had in a very long time. All our meals were excellent. The sweet potatoe biscuits were delicious and the restaurant was recommended by a local couple who have been on the island for over 30 years so we took their advice and are glad we did, Chocolate cake and key lime pie for dessert was awesome. Also thought the ambiance and decorating was comfortable and well done. Would definitly go back again.