I had read reviews of Catherine and Mary's prior to our visit last weekend. Most everyone liked the food but too many comments about the staff hyping up a 4 course meal. The menu reflects that as well as the waitstaff encouraging it. Snacks, Plates, Pasta and Entrees. I couldn't find an entree that worked for me( didn't want a steak) so I said I would choose a pasta dish as an entree. Well, wrong choice of words! I was charged double for an "entree sized" portion, which IMO was not worth $32 for a bowl of Tagliatelle pasta. The Brussels plate was a decent portion and was delicious. The "snacks", or appetizers were eaten well by the group, but nothing I could eat. The Caprese plate was probably the best Caprese salad I have eaten! The trio of gelato for dessert was generous and very good. They did take care with the gluten free aspect, but I feel I should have been told the pasta I ordered was coming as a double in price. All in all, a good evening out but I will be careful when I order there again. It won't keep me from returning, I'm just a little bit wiser.
The ratings tab on this site is not operating, so I will add 4* for service, 5* for food and 3* for value.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.