These folks do a GREAT job on pizza. Our "go to" pizza is the "Madeline Island" special with meats, veggies, loads of cheese (it is Wisconsin after all...we have had it now 5 or 6 times since coming to Bayfield last year. The 22" feeds our family of five which includes three hungry teenage boys, and still leaves some for snacking later. Just had one tonight and as always it was hot and fresh and wonderful. Oh, and when dining in get the sweet potato fries with home made tzatziki ... yum. Oh and one more thing I forgot. Last time we were there we shared the Buffalo Chicken Wings ... large and hot and crispy with traditional buffalo sauce and blue cheese. Licked the plate.
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.