We went back and forth about which steak place to try while we were in NY and finally settled on Gallagher’s!
We visited on a Wednesday evening at 7:30 for my husband’s birthday. He and I shared the porterhouse, while our daughter got the filet mignon. All of it was melt-in-your-mouth delicious — though it did seem overpriced comparatively.
The most interesting thing was that I had noted on our OpenTable reservation that we would be there for a birthday, but we didn’t say anything to the servers about it once we were there. Even so, they brought out a free dessert for my husband and sang to him — completely unexpected! Great, high-end service.
This place is upscale and swanky and a fun place to people-watch, too!
Own or manage this property? Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and much more.